• 0 Posts
  • 38 Comments
Joined 11 months ago
cake
Cake day: August 16th, 2023

help-circle

  • Just because you disagree with a definition, doesn’t mean it’s wrong.

    Every country is culturally diverse, but there’s still statistical common denominator. You have big differences in languages, accents, food, culture in the UK and yet 82% are white British. Same goes for Germany, Japan etc. Every country do their demographic analyses differently, but the point is that they all can have major differences within the same ethic group.

    So we should either agree to use the same definition or agree that it has no meaning and not use that word at all.







  • I don’t know if it’s your reading comprehension or you’re just confused, but I urge you to re-read my comments - I’m not trying to convince you of anything, you clearly made your decision and it doesn’t seem to be based on any empirical evidence.

    You made some bold claims though and I’m here to challenge you on those.

    • You claim to be a “leftie”.
    • You voted remain.
    • You want to reform FPTP and immigration.
    • Apparently reform are the only ones to hit all the boxes.

    So my answer is this… If you vote Reform, you’re not a leftie. If you vote Farage, you’re not a Remainer either. There are other parties who want to reform voting and immigration with better track record, actual councillors and more humane policies.












  • Are you sure you’re a Marxist? Sound more like an American from the 50s…

    Socialism and capitalism are not mutually exclusive.

    Capitalism is an economic system where the capital owner holds the means of production and their operation for profit.

    Sorry to burst your bubble, but China does have companies that operate globally and are for profit, and some of them are even privately owned.

    There are different forms of capitalism. For example: France is mainly welfare capitalism, China is state capitalism (party state capitalism to be more precise) and people would argue that USA is laissez-faire capitalism.

    There are also different types of socialism… France for example is a socialist democracy. China is totalitarian socialism.

    France is a country with a capitalist mode of production. Markets have nothing to do with the distinction between capitalist and socialist modes of production, the ownership of the means of production and thus also the class in control of the state is the defining characteristic.

    Most of the biggest industries in France, from energy to rail, are state owned.

    China is socialist. China has home ownership for personal use, but no private land ownership and ever dwindling private ownership of the means of production. Homes for the purpose of living in, ie personal property, are not a means of production, and houses for rent for the purpose of enriching the owner at the expense of the tenant, ie private property, basically don’t exist.

    Seems like you live in a dream world. 20% of home owners in China have a second (and more) home/s, and they definitely use it for profit.

    Also, leasehold of state property exist all over the globe. It’s not unique to capitalism or socialism or any other ism.