cross-posted from: https://lemmy.world/post/1101309
Everyone is talking about how Meta is trying to Embrace, Extend, and Extinguish the Fediverse. Meta won’t be alone for long in this goal, there will be a lot of capitalist actors that would try to do the same in the long run.
Defederation with them will be a shot in the leg, and handicap the Fediverse movement itself. There will be users/instances in the current Fediverse that would want to federate with them, and banning such instances would create silos and echo chambers.
The way out of this is to focus on the 2nd E - “Extend”. I think we can all agree that UX of Threads app will always probably be the best out of all the federated instances. But that is something that people can still live without. Before long, Meta will tout shortcomings like lack of E2E encryption in the private messages and some other core features, that will create a bigger divide amongst ourselves. The Fediverse developers and community have to keep abreast of Meta on such core features, so that they can never extend the core of the Fediverse.
Let me know of your thoughts!
I think that’s an awful lot of assumptions. The fediverse is not brand new. Maximum user adoption no matter the cost isn’t the only road forward. Threads is no more necessary to the fediverse than Twitter was.
TBH, I think a lot of new Lemmy users are addicted to their social medias and just really, really want to use Threads. Which they should then, but it doesn’t need to subsume the fediverse in order for them to do it. Go make a Threads account. Have fun.
I’m with this. I was just posting on /m/fediverse about the likelihood government agencies will move from announcements via Twitter to announcements via Threads, making it so defedeeration will miss out on public safety announcements, and askign what the strategy would be for that. THIS is the strategy for that.
I agree, even know META has done really good with Threads I love what everyone is doing with the Fediverse and it needs to continue without a large tech giant swallowing it.
