Literally an apartheid state and we’re rooting for characters that are committed to “keeping it safe” (this means further militarizing the border between Piltover and the undercity and killing children on accident and feeling really bad about it). There’s plot elements that expose how bad Piltover is for undercity citizens, but that’s just the other half of both-sidesing the issue and calling it a cycle of violence. No, the REAL and IMMEDIATE threat is Silco, the guy actually committed to resistance against apartheid Piltover and even the Good and Right characters are opposed to him - to the point that they’re more willing to work with Piltover, the state that has been oppressing them their whole lives and which they constantly talk about how its oppressed them their whole lives, to take him down. There’s even the gem at the end where Piltover is on the verge of granting the undercity sovereignty and freedom to end the fighting, but then someone decides to fire a fucking rocket straight into the room this decision is being made in. It almost feels 1 for 1 equivalents being made to Israel and Palestine based on hasbara narratives.
the guy actually committed to resistance against apartheid
the drug-lord objectively lowering the standard of living and life expectancy of ‘his people’, but don’t worry some of that blood money is sponsoring putting him on the throne of a “liberated” state. i think we’re allowed to have stories where nationalists/representatives of oppressed groups can be shitty in their own right, without that equaling an endorsement of the oppression. Should we not criticize the Nation of Islam because of stated support for nationalism? How about the Palestinian Authority?
I think the bigger issue is that we so rarely get to see a “clean” revolution where the opressed class is led by people with good motives. That’s not on Arcane specifically, but there is a lot of media where the scrappy upstarts sucessfully overthrow power only to have the new power be just as evil, but maybe in a different way (Hunger Games is a notable example).
Arcane plays into that ttope somewhat, but I wouldn’t say it plays it straight
They always have to kick the dog, you can’t make the revolutionaries too emphatic.
I kinda agree. It’s a Lib show I won’t deny that.
I think Silco is presented as a bit more complex than that though. The guy is brutal, but season one ends with him ALMOST achieving his goal, Jayce agrees to give the Undercity independence with a few reasonable concessions which Silco agrees to uphold. I feel like an even more Lib version of the show would have had him continue to escalate the conflict our of stubbornness and hate, but not he has a clear goal, pursues it without compromise, and seems happy to end the conflict when his goal is reached. I’ve known a surprising number of Libs who actually sympathize with the character, so I’d argue his writing is pretty effective.
Season 1 was cool.
Season 2 is when everyone cool becomes a cop and does a lot of violence against the oppressed and then we’re supposed to feel bad for the cops I guess. Oh and then the oppressed also become cops because magic big scary thing and then they all die so that the main cops can live.
Libs have zero imagination
They also get just one seat at the table, just one
