• dfc09@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    1 year ago

    Chaotic and lawful are opposite ends of the matrix, evil and good are similarly opposites. Ignoring neutrality, we can look at a punnet square-esque 2x2 grid of chaotic good - chaotic evil -lawful good - lawful evil

    The way I see it (and this is a hotly debated topic, so it’s all pretty firmly in the realm of interpretation) is that lawful good is akin to a benevolent government, chaotic good is akin to Robinhood, lawful evil is akin to a fascist regime or dictatorship, chaotic evil is akin to the joker.

    There’s a lot of nuance between those extremes, of course, but to make broad strokes you can ask “are they working within or without a strong system” to get lawful vs chaotic, and “are they trying to help others or hurt others” to get good and evil.

    Using those questions gives a good basis to start dissecting people and characters.

    Hitler worked within the political system to create a new totalitarian regime and harm the people who fell outside it. Lawful evil.

    Robinhood flaunted laws and committed crimes in the pursuit of helling those in need. Chaotic good.

    You’ll note that chaotic, whether good or evil, doesn’t build societies or ideologies. They’re more focused on their own goals. Lawful creates structure for societies to confirm to.

    • neatchee@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      2
      ·
      1 year ago

      This is a great start but I think the most important of the many nuances is that lawful doesn’t mean governmental, and chaotic doesn’t mean anarchic.

      A king who acts purely on whim with no consistency to the rule of law, even if there are supposed to be rules to follow, is chaotic

      A paladin who follows an ancient code passed down through a single master/apprentice relationship for generations is Lawful

      I’ve always seen it as: lawful = there is a higher authority to which the character is committed, even if they’re the only one committed to it. Chaotic =acting only/mostly with your own purpose at heart, even if that is wrapped up in a lawful-looking package.

      tl;dr: chaotic characters can use legal systems, and powerful characters can be fiercely independent

      • dfc09@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        2
        ·
        1 year ago

        I agree!! I tried to parse my own comment as “hey this is a big fat opinion soup” just because the alignment chart is highly debated and often forgone entirely as too restrictive. Lots of motivations that buck the chart entirely.